Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Can anyone ELI5 what Oxide's offer is? I've looked at their website and still got no clue. Is it hardware + software I can purchase and use on-premise? Is it a PaaS / yet another cloud provider?


I believe you're being downvoted because there is already a big thread about this here, though I think that's a bit unfair to you. I haven't posted in that thread yet because I wanted to let others say what is meaningful about the product to them, but this seems like a good place to put my reply. Regardless of all that: it is hardware + software you can purchase and use on-premise, that's correct.

The differentiator from virtually all existing on-prem cloud products is that we are a single vendor who has designed the hardware and software (which is as open source as we can possibly make it, by the way, hence announcements like this) to work well together. Most products combine various other products from various vendors, and are effectively selling you integration. We believe that that leads to all kinds of problems that our product solves.

Another factor here is that we only have two SKUs: a half rack and a full rack. You don't buy Oxide 1U at a time, you buy it a rack at a time. By designing the entire rack as a cohesive unit, we can do a lot of things that you simply cannot do in the 1U form factor. There is a running joke that we talk about our fans all the time, and it's true. Because our sleds have a larger form factor than a traditional 1U, we can use larger fans. This means we can run them at a lower RPM, which means power savings. That's the deliberate design choice. But we also have gained accidental benefits from doing things like this: lower RPM also means that our servers are way quieter than others. That's pretty neat. Some early prospective customers literally asked if the thing is on when it was demo'd to them, because it's so quiet. Is that a reason to buy a server? Not necessarily, but it's just a fun example of some of the things that end up happening when you re-think a product as a whole, rather than as an integration exercise.


Thanks so much for elaborating!


On-prem, fully-integrated compute and storage solution with cloud-like APIs to provision resources, all with a commitment to open source.


Do you know if they support GPUs or whatever is needed to host LLM models?


The current product does not have any GPUs in it. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39183072


Mainframe 2.0


This is really not accurate in any way that matters I don't think. It's a mainframe in as much as you buy a rack and spec it out. It's not a mainframe in that the performance is typical server performance rather than the mainframe profile which is very different and requires different considerations, the compute model is typical server compute rather than the mainframe compute model which (aside from compatibility layers) is a radically different environment to build software for.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: