Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> We’re working on a comparable UI for Windows devices

As a Linux user and fan of good GUI apps, it always bums me out I'm stuck with the CLI-only options for apps like Tailscale. Even for a simple tray icon I have to resort to buggy GNOME extensions.

I understand the fragmented ecosystem and small user-base on the desktop Linux side make it hard to justify, but I hope that changes one day!

 help



Re: buggy GNOME extensions, it drives me nuts that GNOME has no built in support for menu bar icons/app indicators.

There's a whole class of GUI apps that should run in the background until needed, and GNOME just has no solution here. I really don't get why they removed this functionality.

I don't want a "service" model where you start/stop gui apps via systemd. And I don't want to keep a window around for no good reason.


GNOME 44 has built-in support finally, but they're hidden in the quick settings menu. I prefer having them in the tray so I can see if they're running without having to click around.

this may have been what you were referring to with “ buggy GNOME extensions”, but in case it wasn’t:

https://tailscale.com/docs/features/client/linux-systray


It wasn't actually! I've been using a third party extension that tries to provide a similar tray icon (after moving from a different extension that doesn't support my version of GNOME) but it's really flaky. I'll try this. Thanks for the tip.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: