Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wow, this is very pretty. Members-only section feels hokey, I don't like it. Otherwise great.

I feel stupid saying this because it seems unreasonable of me to believe. But I feel that I won't enjoy movies as much as I used to, when I knew Roger Ebert was going to write about them.



I'm glad you like the site. It's been quite the undertaking...

And I agree, our Members-only section is definitely hokey right now! But give us a few months to get it fully up and running, and I hope it will become a useful resource for the intense cinephile and/or Ebert fan, something like ESPN Insider for a fantasy sports aficionado.


Any chance that you'd package the site up and submit it to the Internet Archive once its been polished?


When it's not 'too soon', give our most loved movie reviewers in Australia a go: http://www.abc.net.au/atthemovies/

Can't remember meeting anyone who didn't like or at least appreciate their reviews.


Most reviews are for before you see the movie, but some reviews are great for afterwards. I go to Rotten Tomatoes to help me decide what to see. If Pauline Kael has an essay/review for an old movie, I'll read it after I've seen it, or before I see it a second time.

For me Ebert's reviews filled both roles.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: